The Texas Business Court at Work: Lessons from Case Filing to Jury Verdict — Part 1

October 2, 2026
By Bart F. Higgins
and Bayley S. Clark

The Texas Business Court is still a relatively new forum, having begun accepting cases on September 1, 2024. In August 2026, Shields Legal Group tried one of the earliest cases in the Texas Business Court to a jury verdict in the First Business Court Division.  That experience, spanning every stage of the litigation from initial filing through trial, provided valuable insight into how the Business Court operates in practice and offers several important lessons for attorneys and litigants navigating this evolving forum.

1. Waste No Time: The Business Court Is Delivering on Its Promise of Timely Case Resolution.

In its first local rule, the Texas Business Court states that it is “dedicated to the fair, efficient, and timely resolution of business disputes.”[1] Consistent with that mandate, the court initially set our case for trial just over one year after it was placed on the Business Court docket.

The court’s scheduling order likewise reflected its commitment to efficiency. Pleading, discovery, and dispositive-motion deadlines were all compressed into a roughly one-year timeline. In our experience, the Business Court was generally reluctant to extend deadlines. As a result, attorneys should carefully evaluate how scheduling-order deadlines interact, particularly when planning discovery, summary judgment briefing, and obtaining rulings before trial.

Discovery requires early and sustained attention. Before seeking court intervention, parties must engage in meaningful, good-faith efforts to resolve or narrow discovery disputes.[2]  If those efforts are unsuccessful, the parties must utilize the court’s dispute-letter process, which includes a seven-day response period for the opposing party.[3] This additional procedural step, combined with the court’s emphasis on efficient case management, leaves little room for delay and rewards litigants who address discovery issues promptly.

Recent material amendments to Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 166a further reinforce the accelerated pace of litigation. Summary judgment motions generally must be heard within 90 days of filing,[4] and courts are required to issue written rulings within 90 days after the hearing or submission date.[5] These deadlines make strategic planning and early summary judgment motion practice more important than ever.

Attorneys appearing before the Business Court should expect an expedited litigation schedule and should prepare for a forum that is committed to moving cases toward resolution on a compressed timeline. If delay is central to your client’s litigation strategy, the Business Court may not be the preferred forum.

2. Get to the Point: The Business Court Expects Clear, Concise, and Well-Reasoned Pleadings and Motions.

The Business Court expects attorneys to get to the point. Pleadings and motions should be clear, concise, and focused on the issues that matter. To reinforce that expectation, the court imposes strict word limits: 3,000 words for discovery motions and responses and 7,500 words for all other motions and responses, including dispositive motions.[6]  Those limits are not merely aspirational. Each filing must include a certificate of compliance verifying the word count, underscoring the court’s commitment to concise advocacy.[7]

Discovery disputes are subject to even more stringent requirements. Under the Business Court’s local rules, dispute letters and responses are generally limited to 700 words.[8] These limitations require counsel to distill complex issues to their essence and present them in a manner that allows the court to quickly identify and resolve the matters in dispute.

In our experience, the court’s emphasis on brevity enhances, rather than diminishes, judicial engagement. The judges appeared exceptionally well prepared for hearings and routinely focused their questions on the issues most likely to affect the outcome of the case. Likewise, discovery disputes raised through the Business Court’s dispute-letter process were addressed promptly and efficiently.

Attorneys should also recognize that Business Court judges are willing to engage deeply with the substantive documents that often drive commercial disputes. Because the court’s docket is concentrated on complex business-to-business litigation, contracts and related transactional documents frequently take center stage. Based on our experience, attorneys should expect the court to carefully scrutinize contract language, apply established principles of Texas contract interpretation, and hold parties to the bargain they made.

The takeaway is straightforward: write with precision, lead with your strongest points, and assume the court will closely read both your filings and the contracts at issue. Brevity and clarity are not simply preferred in the Business Court; they are expected.

3. Narrow the Issues Early: Use Procedural Tools Strategically

Texas procedure provides litigants with several tools to streamline a case and reduce the issues that ultimately reach trial. Motions for summary judgment,[9] Rule 166(g) motions,[10] and motions to exclude or limit expert testimony can all serve as effective mechanisms for narrowing disputed issues and focusing the court’s attention on matters genuinely requiring resolution.

These tools align with the Business Court’s emphasis on the efficient and timely resolution of complex business disputes. By eliminating unnecessary claims, defenses, or issues before trial, litigants can help the court manage cases more effectively and concentrate resources on the matters that truly remain in dispute.

Our experience suggests that parties should be proactive in identifying opportunities to narrow the scope of the litigation. Litigants should not hesitate to file motions directed at discrete issues when appropriate. They should also be prepared for the Business Court to do the same. In particular, the court may, sua sponte, request supplemental briefing or invoke procedural devices such as Rule 166(g) to identify and resolve specific issues before trial.

The lesson is straightforward: litigants who actively work to narrow the issues are likely to find that their approach aligns with the Business Court’s expectations and commitment to efficient case management.

Conclusion

The Texas Business Court was created to provide a fair, efficient, and timely forum for resolving complex business disputes. Litigants who choose that forum should be prepared for a court that is committed to those objectives and expects the same level of diligence and efficiency from counsel.

Our experience suggests that the Business Court places a premium on preparation, concise advocacy, adherence to deadlines, and the early identification of issues that can be narrowed or resolved before trial. Attorneys should expect a demanding yet highly engaged litigation environment, where discovery, motion practice, and pretrial proceedings move at an accelerated pace and judicial attention to the issues is substantial.

The takeaway is straightforward: success in the Business Court requires proactive case management, strategic use of procedural tools, and a willingness to move quickly. Attorneys who are prepared to litigate efficiently and focus on the issues that truly matter will be best positioned to succeed in this evolving forum.

This is the first in a series examining Shields Legal Group’s experience litigating a Texas Business Court case from filing through jury verdict. Stay tuned for additional lessons and practical insights from our Business Court litigation and trial team.

Note: This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute or contain legal advice. Consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction regarding your specific situation.

Read The Texas Business Court at Work: Insights on Summary Judgment Practice — Part 2


[1] Local Rules of the Texas Business Court (“BCLR”) 1.

[2] BCLR 4(d)(1).

[3] Id.

[4] Tex. R. Civ. P. 166a(g).

[5] Tex. R. Civ. P. 166a(i).

[6] BCLR 5(a)(i).

[7] BCLR 5(a)(iii).

[8] BCLR 4(d)(1), (2).

[9] See Tex. R. Civ. P. 166a.

[10] See Tex. R. Civ. P. 166(g).

Recent Posts

M&A Deal Killers — Part 2: Required Seller Restructures

As a business owner, we understand that you have spent years growing your business and its potential for the future. Once you decide to sell your business, however, day-to-day operations can no longer be your sole focus. You must also navigate the procedural and...

The mission of Shields Legal is to bring strategic business insight, professional judgment and competence to your company’s business and legal issues.